A Career Can Be Successful and Still Lose Its Meaning

Image: The Excommunication of Spinoza (1907), Samuel Hirszenberg.

“Don’t you know what you want?” and “Is there a true career waiting for you?” These questions share an underlying assumption: that there is a truth about ourselves waiting to be discovered. As though, behind the choices we make, the careers we build, and the paths we follow, there were a truer self waiting for the moment to reveal itself.

This idea runs through much of the way we learn to think about our professional and personal lives. We are encouraged to discover our vocation, identify our passions, recognize our talents, and find out what we really want. The promise is seductive: somewhere within us lies an answer capable of organizing our choices and giving meaning to our journey.

But what happens when that answer never comes? Or when what once seemed to be the answer no longer makes sense?

We spend years building our lives, making choices, and taking on responsibilities. Some things go as planned; others do not. And even when everything seems to have worked out, there is no guarantee that the life we have built will feel like our own.

In clinical practice, this question arises in different ways. Some people have built solid careers but no longer recognize themselves in what they do. Others have met the expectations of their families, their workplaces, and themselves, yet begin to wonder why certain achievements have lost their meaning. And some, when faced with the possibility of change, discover how difficult it is to let go of an identity built over many years. These people do not necessarily want to abandon what they have built. Often, they are trying to understand what has changed in their relationship with their own choices.

As part of my continuing education in psychoanalysis, I have been rereading Spinoza through the work of André Martins, a philosopher, psychoanalyst, and professor at the Federal University of Rio de Janeiro (UFRJ). The Spinoza I knew was the rationalist who wrote the Ethics using the geometric method, inspired by Euclid's structure of demonstration. What I am encountering now is the Spinoza of affects, desire, and the power to act. Ética pelo método geométrico, inspirado na estrutura demonstrativa de Euclides. O que encontro agora é o Spinoza dos afetos, do desejo e da potência de agir.

These are not two different Spinozas, but two ways of approaching the same philosophy. The rigor of his thought does not exclude a dynamic understanding of human existence. It is through this rigor that Spinoza seeks to understand how we are affected, how we desire, why we suffer, and how we might expand our capacity to act.

Gilles Deleuze called Spinoza "the prince of philosophers." His reading brought back to the center of this philosophy a question that also seems essential to clinical practice: not merely what we think or know about ourselves, but what we are capable of living.

When thinking about work and careers, this reading introduces something fundamental. According to Deleuze, Spinoza's philosophy is a practical philosophy, driven by a question: how can we increase our power to act? Here, the power to act refers to our capacity to think, create, desire, and affect the world, even as we are affected by it.

This question changes the problem. Instead of searching for a true professional identity, as though there were a definitive vocation waiting to be discovered, we can investigate how our experiences, relationships, and choices expand or restrict our capacity to exist and act.

This power should not be confused with performance, productivity, or efficiency. Someone may hold a position of great responsibility, accumulate achievements and recognition, and yet experience a diminishing capacity to think, create, and desire.

The question then becomes something else: what, in our relationship with work, strengthens our power to act? Which encounters, experiences, and activities expand our possibilities? And which relationships, even when accompanied by recognition and success, end up restricting them?

From this perspective, reconsidering a career does not require abandoning it. It may mean transforming the way we inhabit it, recognizing the affects that run through our choices, and finding other ways of relating to what we do.

For Spinoza, desire is the very dynamic of our existence, what moves and constitutes us, rather than the expression of a lack that needs to be filled. Affects, in turn, are not secondary disturbances that reason should eliminate. They are the ways in which we experience our encounters with the world, with others, and with ourselves. Some encounters increase our power to act. Others diminish it. And we are not always able to distinguish between them immediately.

This is also where Spinoza differs from certain strands of psychoanalysis, particularly the Lacanian tradition, in which desire is articulated in relation to lack. This tension does not need to be resolved for the dialogue to be productive. Spinoza and psychoanalysis do not offer the same understanding of desire, but both help us question how we become attached to particular ways of existing.

This perspective challenges the idea that living better depends on discovering some definitive inner truth. There is no ready-made, authentic identity hidden beneath social expectations, waiting to be revealed. This does not deny each person's singularity or the importance of self-knowledge. It simply recognizes that who we are cannot be separated from the relationships we form, the experiences we live through, and the possibilities we encounter, or fail to encounter, throughout our lives.

Imagination also takes on a different place in this reading. It is no longer merely a source of error or illusion but becomes a constitutive dimension of human experience. Through imagination, we assign meaning, anticipate possibilities, and construct expectations. The image we have of ourselves can sustain a trajectory, provide continuity to our story, and enable us to make commitments. But it can also imprison us when we can no longer imagine ourselves differently.

Consider, for example, someone who has spent decades being recognized for their competence, leadership, and professional success. This identity is not false. It was built through real experiences, emotional investments, choices, and sacrifices. Yet the recognition that once brought satisfaction may no longer have the same effect. The suffering that emerges does not necessarily mean that the person chose the wrong career or lived a life that was not their own. It may indicate that the relationship between their history, desires, and possibilities is changing.

Psychoanalysis, in turn, recognizes that we are not entirely transparent to ourselves. Our desires cannot be reduced to the conscious explanations we give for our choices. Conflicts, identifications, repetitions, and emotional experiences participate in shaping our lives without our being immediately able to recognize them. This, however, does not make clinical work a search for a true self hidden beneath these determining influences.

In Winnicott's work, the distinction between the true and false self does not refer to a ready-made personal essence waiting to be found. His reflections on spontaneity, creativity, and the sense of reality in one's own experience point to the importance of living in a way that is less dominated by the demands of adapting to one's environment. Life in society requires commitments, responsibilities, and adaptations. The problem arises when adaptation becomes so predominant that a person begins to lose the feeling of being actively and fully engaged in their own existence.

There is a difference between building a career and becoming entirely identified with it; between recognizing the value of what has been achieved and feeling that there is no longer room to desire something different. This is why, when someone comes to therapy saying they no longer know what they want, that statement need not be understood as a lack of self-knowledge. It may mark the beginning of an inquiry into how their desires have been formed, what still moves them, and which ways of living have become difficult to sustain.

Likewise, the question of whether there is a true career can take a different direction. Instead of searching for a profession that definitively corresponds to an inner identity, we can explore which relationships with work foster a more creative, more personally meaningful experience, one less determined by the need to live up to an image of success.

This shift does not provide ready-made answers, and psychotherapy is not a tool for deciding whether someone should change jobs, abandon a career, or reorganize their life. Clinical work does not replace external expectations with a new prescription for how to live. It creates conditions in which a person can listen to their own experience, recognize their conflicts, and expand the possibilities of relating to themselves and to the world.

Questioning the path we have taken does not mean denying what we have built. A career may have been legitimate, important, and fulfilling for many years, even if it no longer gives rise to the same feelings today.

Perhaps the contribution of bringing Spinoza and psychoanalysis into dialogue lies in replacing the question of who we really are with another, one less concerned with revealing a definitive identity and more attentive to how we are living. What, in the life you have built, still moves you? And what no longer makes sense? These questions do not demand immediate answers. They can open up space to understand what has changed, what remains, and what has not yet found the conditions in which to exist.

After all, why do we assume that we need to discover who we are before we can begin to live differently?